search instagram arrow-down

Blog post archive

Follow Traynor On The Trail on WordPress.com

Blogs I Follow

Brands Valued: Vaude And PYUA Achieve Top Sustainability Ranking

Credit: Vaude

Rank a Brand represents an interesting evolution in the role of gear reviews for outdoor clothing, footwear and equipment. Stepping back from individual product evaluation, the Netherlands-based independent brand comparison website for consumers assesses brands’ performance in several areas of sustainability and corporate responsibility.

To be assessed a brand must be nominated and reach a threshold of consumer interest. Whilst this could be manipulated, it’s hard to see why a brand without sound credentials would bother. Of course, the rankings can only be comparative within those selected rather than universal. In that way, it’s no different to many outdoor industry awards’ processes that require formal nomination, possibly with a fee due, and judged by an independent committee.

Its website notes,

Our position is that brands should demonstrate to their consumers that they have actually implemented sustainable and socially responsible policies. The brand has the responsibility to prove so and to be transparent about it. Therefore, we only use publicly available information. So it is crucial for brands to make all relevant information accessible on their website or in a public CSR report or sustainability report.’

A recent report on outdoor apparel brands posed the question, ‘So are these clothes not only good for enjoying nature, but also good for nature itself? Without workers manufacturing this clothing being exploited, of course?’

Environmental awareness has a high profile in the outdoor industries but is translated into meaningful action by relatively few brands. The report notes, ‘The outdoor sector does need to be more transparent, though. Especially climate reporting was limited. Except for VAUDE, few brands reported a climate footprint, let alone a smaller footprint than in the previous reporting year. Reporting about renewable energy was often also too limited to convince us that brands were really frontrunners in the energy transition.’

Product developments have taken centre stage for many years as also commented on by Rank a Brand, ‘Instead, brands often reported on their use of environmentally preferred raw materials and phasing out of suspect chemicals. Especially PYUA obtained a high score here. But it often remained unclear which materials exactly were used to what extent in the brands’ collections, and whether chemicals were eliminated during the manufacturing process, rather than only in the end product. Reporting on waste and packaging was also limited, VAUDE being an exception.’

Beyond product and the natural environment, the report also commented on the human dimension of responsibility, ‘Good labour conditions, finally, were actually emphasized by brands as much as environmental protection. Many readily disclosed a list of direct suppliers, are a member of a multi-stakeholder initiative and reported on human rights in their supply chain. Still, even frontrunners could not yet guarantee that all their workers overseas actually receive living wages.’

It came as no surprise to me that Vaude topped the list as an all-rounder. Consistent policy initiatives implemented, monitored and shared have underlined how the German brand has been an industry leader for decades. My Vaude Eco Log t-shirt is still in use almost 25 years after its acquisition. The only way I could consider recycling it would be as a museum exhibit – or maybe framed and hung on a wall at home to remind me of adventures outdoors.

Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Alex Roddie

Editor & Outdoor Writer

Cycling Around Japan

The Travelling Bean Counter - A naive but enthusiastic cyclist tackling the mountains Japan over approximately 4 months, to experience japanese culture and learn the language. https://www.instagram.com/thetravellingbeancounter/

RTW Roxy

A girl travelling around the world on a motorcycle.

In Flow with Otto

Creativity is within us all

Back Road Journal

Little treasures discovered while exploring the back roads of life

William Kemsley Jr.

Backpacking Footnotes